Each scholarly article type follows the double-anonymous review model with at least two independent external expert reports.
01Original Research Articles
Theoretical, methodological, computational or behavioural advances in AI or decision sciences.
State the question, contribution and relationship to established work. Describe the mathematical, computational, experimental or behavioural design sufficiently for critical assessment. Match the analysis to the claims, distinguish exploratory from confirmatory work and explain uncertainty and limitations. Formal results require precise assumptions and arguments; empirical conclusions require appropriate comparisons and evidence.
02Benchmark and Evaluation Articles
Defensible comparisons that establish tasks, protocols or substantive evidence about methods.
Define the target task, intended users, eligible methods, dataset selection, metrics and comparison protocol. Explain tuning effort, computational resources and restrictions affecting fairness. Publish informative method characteristics and uncertainty alongside aggregate scores. A benchmark should establish useful knowledge about performance or evaluation, rather than merely produce another ordered list.
03Data and Software Resource Articles
Documented datasets, evaluation suites or research software with demonstrated scientific value.
Identify the research need and explain how the resource addresses it. Document provenance, collection or construction, versions, quality checks, access conditions, licences and known limitations. Supply usable documentation and a substantive demonstration. Explain maintenance responsibilities and restrictions without promising permanent support that has not been arranged.
04Replication and Robustness Studies
Tests of published claims, including informative null results and unsuccessful reproductions.
Identify the precise published claim being examined and distinguish direct reproduction, independent replication and extension. Record deviations from the original design, unavailable materials and attempts to resolve uncertainty. Report confirmatory and contradictory findings with equivalent care. A failure to reproduce should be analysed before being attributed to error or misconduct.
05Reviews and Evidence Syntheses
Critical surveys or systematic reviews answering a defined research question.
Define a substantive question and explain how evidence was located, selected, assessed and synthesised. Systematic reviews should provide reproducible search and eligibility procedures; critical surveys should justify their coverage. Separate empirical evidence, theoretical arguments and editorial interpretation. Produce an analytical contribution beyond a catalogue of publications.
06Brief Research Communications
Complete, focused results, diagnostic experiments or methodological corrections.
Present a complete focused contribution, such as a concise theorem, diagnostic experiment or consequential methodological correction. Brevity does not reduce the need for adequate methods, evidence and limitations. Material necessary to evaluate the central claim must remain accessible with the submission.
07Perspectives and Research Agendas
Evidence-grounded arguments about conceptual, methodological or governance questions.
Develop an evidence-grounded argument about an emerging conceptual, methodological or governance question. Identify assumptions and competing interpretations, and distinguish supported observations from proposed directions. A research agenda should explain which questions matter, what would count as progress and what evidence is presently missing.