For reviewers
An expert judgement, with a clear account of its limits.
Assess the contribution and the evidence. Explain essential concerns, respect confidentiality and distinguish required corrections from optional extensions.
AI and research integrity
Keep scientific assessments human, protect confidential material and record any approved administrative assistance.
Reviewer invitations and assignments follow the journal’s editorial process, with conflicts and confidentiality addressed for each manuscript.
Preparing a constructive review report
Before accepting an invitation, assess subject and methodological competence, conflicts and availability. Inform the editor promptly if the work requires expertise outside the reviewer's competence. A reviewer should examine the main manuscript and the supporting material relevant to the claims, identify inaccessible components and distinguish essential corrections from optional extensions.
A useful report briefly identifies the contribution, explains the main evidential or methodological concerns, gives specific actionable comments and states the limits of the review performed. Cite a manuscript location when possible. Explain why a requested experiment, analysis or citation is needed. Do not demand irrelevant self-citations, promote a competing service or require an entirely new research programme as a condition for addressing a bounded submission.
The recommendation is advice to the editor. Give the authors a fair account of substantive concerns and reserve genuinely confidential matters, such as suspected misconduct or identifying information, for the confidential channel. Do not use confidential comments to make unsupported personal allegations. The journal's confidentiality, co-review and AI rules apply throughout.
Assessing security claims
Identify the principal security or privacy claim and examine whether the threat model, assumptions and evidence support it. Assess novelty through insight, capabilities or reliable understanding, including useful negative findings. A higher benchmark score is not automatically a meaningful security improvement, and a formal result should be judged within its stated model.
Check comparison fairness, leakage, class prevalence, uncertainty and relevant operating costs. Distinguish limitations that undermine a claim from additional experiments that would merely extend it. Explain the practical or theoretical consequence of each major concern and request proportionate evidence or clarification.
Reviewing sensitive research materials
Assess whether authorisation, disclosure and data handling are adequately explained. Notify the editor of concerns about live vulnerabilities or unnecessary exposure rather than seeking access to affected systems yourself. Reviewers must not run untrusted code on operational systems or obtain restricted material outside the authorised review arrangements.
Record which artifacts, proofs or supporting data were examined and any limits on access or execution. If specialist assessment is needed, request it through the editor. Do not equate unavailable public artifacts with misconduct; evaluate the stated reason and whether a sufficient alternative basis for scientific assessment exists.
Human and policy evidence
Assess behavioural, qualitative, economic and policy research using standards appropriate to the question and design. Examine sampling, contextual interpretation, analytical transparency and the distinction between association and causal explanation. Strong purely technical and interdisciplinary submissions are both eligible; do not require an unrelated disciplinary component.
What the review model means
The adopted model requires double-anonymous review and at least two independent external expert reports for scholarly articles. The handling editor assesses the evidence and makes the decision; reports are advice rather than votes.
Read the complete peer review policyPublishing information
Journal information
Read the journal’s publication frequency, charges, editorial policies and discovery information.
- Publication charges
- Free publication through 31 January 2028
- Publication frequency
- Annual: one issue per calendar year
- Indexing status
- No inclusion claimed