Manuscript template
Prepare the main manuscript and keep author identities in the separate title page.
Download manuscript templateFor authors
A practical route through scope, manuscript files, scientific reporting and the declarations needed for a fair review.
Prepare an accurate AI-use declaration, verify references and explain the provenance of figures, data and code.
Recommended before submission. Check sections, declarations, citations and references, then prepare a Word draft with this journal’s template.
The journal is led by Editor-in-Chief Associate Professor Rahul Thakkar. Manuscript reception remains closed while the submission workflow is prepared. You may use the guidance and Manuscript Pre-check to prepare your work; preparation is not a journal submission. The opening date and authorised submission route will be announced here.
Downloading a template or preparing evidence does not submit a manuscript. The formal submission route will be announced when the journal opens.
Use these editable files alongside the instructions below. They are preparation resources; they do not create an active submission.
Prepare the main manuscript and keep author identities in the separate title page.
Download manuscript templateRecord the author list, affiliations, contributions and relevant declarations separately.
Download title pageExplain the contribution, journal fit and related work for editorial assessment.
Download cover letterAddress each review point and identify revisions or explain a reasoned disagreement.
Download response to reviewersPrepare an anonymised manuscript, a separate title page, a cover letter and any supporting files needed to assess the work. The title page should give the full journal title, manuscript title, article type, author names and affiliations, corresponding author details, contribution statement and relevant declarations. Keep identities and identifying acknowledgements out of the review manuscript. Anonymise document properties and explain any repository link that could reveal authorship. Ethics, data-access and methodological declarations needed to assess the science must remain in anonymised form in the review manuscript. Provide identifying approvals or other confidential evidence separately through the authorised editorial route.
Prepare an editable DOCX manuscript using the journal structure; a review PDF may accompany it. Authors using LaTeX or another specialist format should seek an agreed alternative route before submission and provide a compiled review PDF and source when requested. Supply original figure files and an accurate reference list for production. Initial submissions may use a consistent readable reference style. The final house style is specified during production. References to data and software should identify the version or release and a persistent identifier where available.
Use a specific title, an informative abstract and descriptive keywords. State the research question, its relationship to prior work, the methods and assumptions, the evidence, limitations and conclusions. For empirical work, distinguish results from interpretation. For theoretical, conceptual or qualitative work, use a structure that makes the reasoning and evidence traceable. Include all applicable declarations and cite supplementary material in the manuscript.
There is no fixed initial-submission word limit in this guide. Provide a word count and use the length needed for a complete, focused account. The editor may request shortening or restructuring. A later published article-type limit will apply to submissions received after its stated effective date; any exceptional change for a manuscript already under consideration must be communicated to its authors.
A preparation file or saved evidence record does not constitute a journal submission. Formal submission requires the journal's announced submission route, author approval and completion of the required declarations. Authors should use the manuscript reference in subsequent correspondence and identify the version to which a query relates.
A revised submission should include an updated anonymised manuscript, any revised supporting files and a response addressing every editorial and reviewer point. Identify where changes were made and explain any reasoned disagreement. Keep the response professional and provide evidence for disputed technical issues. Do not silently substitute datasets, analyses or author lists; disclose consequential changes for editorial assessment.
Journal-specific standards
Use the guidance relevant to your design. A formal, conceptual or behavioural study should not add unrelated experiments merely to resemble another article type.
Search and recommendation studies should define the information task, intended users, collection and unit of evaluation. Report how queries or topics were produced and how relevance judgments were obtained, including assessor expertise, instructions and disagreement handling. Explain the consequences of incomplete judgments or collection coverage.
Separate training, development and evaluation material in a way that reflects the intended use. Report near-duplicate handling and possible contamination through shared documents, queries or judgments. Justify comparison systems, metrics and aggregation. Include uncertainty or suitable repeated evaluation where the design permits, and distinguish improvements in offline metrics from evidence of benefit to users.
Ontologies, knowledge graphs and metadata systems should explain the concepts represented, source selection, transformation rules and intended boundaries. State how entities, relationships and identifiers were created or aligned, and describe curation, validation and maintenance. Coverage, consistency and correctness are different properties and should be evaluated accordingly.
Identify source rights and compatible reuse conditions for both the resource and its components. Record the release examined and provide enough provenance to trace important transformations. A resource assembled from public websites is not automatically unrestricted. Explain how personal information, culturally sensitive knowledge and contested classifications were handled.
Studies of information seeking, interpretation and use should explain recruitment, inclusion criteria, setting and the rationale for the sample. Describe instruments, tasks, interview protocols or observation procedures and how these relate to the research question. Separate participants' reported experiences from observed behaviour and from the authors' interpretations.
Qualitative studies should describe the analytical tradition, development of codes or themes, the role of researchers and relevant reflexivity. Provide a traceable explanation connecting evidence to findings, using appropriately de-identified examples. Explain language, translation and contextual considerations. Do not imply statistical representativeness where the design supports contextual or theoretical insight instead.
Bibliometric and scholarly communication research should report the database, retrieval date, complete query, document filters and relevant coverage limitations. Describe author and institution disambiguation, duplicate handling, citation windows, counting methods and any normalisation. Explain the effects of language, field, document type and database selection on the findings.
Use indicators to investigate the stated question and interpret them within their limits. Citation counts and journal-level measures should not be presented as direct measurements of an individual paper's quality or a person's merit. Disclose relationships with the entities assessed and examine whether missing records or classification choices alter the conclusions. Requests for citations must have a scholarly justification.
Research involving Indigenous Peoples, community-held knowledge or culturally sensitive collections should explain relevant community authority, permissions and governance arrangements. Describe local participation or partnership where appropriate, the intended benefits and how communities' interests informed collection, interpretation, access and publication decisions.
Institutional approval and the availability of material online do not settle every question of authority or appropriate reuse. Explain restrictions on sacred, secret, sensitive or community-controlled knowledge and respect agreed conditions for attribution and access. Openness should be pursued in ways compatible with legitimate rights and responsibilities. Authors may explain relevant CARE principles and applicable community protocols rather than assume unrestricted release is always appropriate.
Research on conversational search, retrieval-augmented generation and knowledge assistants should identify the information sources, collection dates, system components and evaluation tasks. Explain how source support, citation accuracy, retrieval coverage and unsupported answers were assessed. Model fluency should not be treated as evidence of information correctness.
Where the claim concerns human use, describe the users, tasks, comparison conditions and relevant measures of understanding, effort or decision quality. Examine important failure modes, uncertainty and differences between user groups where supported by the design. Document material system changes during the study and distinguish an evaluated prototype from a service shown to work reliably in deployment.
Explain restrictions involving proprietary collections, licensed databases, personal data or community permissions at submission. Identify what reviewers can examine and whether lawful independent access is possible. Offer a feasible alternative such as a documented query procedure, de-identified extract, synthetic example or controlled verification arrangement, while explaining what that alternative cannot establish.
Cite datasets, software and knowledge resources as research outputs, including persistent identifiers and release information where available. Retain the versions supporting the reported analysis. Distinguish materials available for reuse from materials actually examined or independently tested; neither a link nor a data statement is a certificate of validity.
Adapt these examples to what actually occurred. Keep science-relevant information in the anonymised manuscript and provide identifying evidence separately when needed.
The evaluation uses [collection and release]. Topics and relevance judgments were produced by [process]. The evaluated code and configuration are available at [repository and version]. Access restrictions and known coverage limitations are [details].
The study concerns [community or collection]. Relevant permissions and governance arrangements were established through [authority and process]. Publication and reuse conditions are [conditions]. Community participation and intended benefits are described in [section].
The source material cannot be released because [specific restriction]. Review access is [arrangement]. The available alternative verification materials are [materials and location], which support [claims] but do not permit assessment of [limitations].
Publishing information
Read the journal’s publication frequency, charges, editorial policies and discovery information.