For reviewers

An expert judgement, with a clear account of its limits.

Assess the contribution and the evidence. Explain essential concerns, respect confidentiality and distinguish required corrections from optional extensions.

AI and research integrity

Keep scientific assessments human, protect confidential material and record any approved administrative assistance.

Read the practical guide
Independent expert review.

Reviewer invitations and assignments follow the journal’s editorial process, with conflicts and confidentiality addressed for each manuscript.

Preparing a constructive review report

Before accepting an invitation, assess subject and methodological competence, conflicts and availability. Inform the editor promptly if the work requires expertise outside the reviewer's competence. A reviewer should examine the main manuscript and the supporting material relevant to the claims, identify inaccessible components and distinguish essential corrections from optional extensions.

A useful report briefly identifies the contribution, explains the main evidential or methodological concerns, gives specific actionable comments and states the limits of the review performed. Cite a manuscript location when possible. Explain why a requested experiment, analysis or citation is needed. Do not demand irrelevant self-citations, promote a competing service or require an entirely new research programme as a condition for addressing a bounded submission.

The recommendation is advice to the editor. Give the authors a fair account of substantive concerns and reserve genuinely confidential matters, such as suspected misconduct or identifying information, for the confidential channel. Do not use confidential comments to make unsupported personal allegations. The journal's confidentiality, co-review and AI rules apply throughout.

Assessing the information science contribution

Assess whether the question and conclusions contribute to information or knowledge processes and whether the intended readership is clear. Judge the method against the question rather than favouring a particular computational or empirical tradition. Conceptual, qualitative and critical work should receive an assessment appropriate to its form of reasoning and evidence.

For system papers, distinguish a new implementation from a demonstrated research contribution. For resource papers, examine provenance, documentation, coverage and rights alongside technical quality. Do not require experiments unrelated to the central claim or dismiss a contextual finding solely because it does not claim universal generalisation.

Examining evidence and evaluation

Consider whether comparison conditions, relevance judgments, sampling and analytical choices support the conclusions. Check for data leakage, unsupported extrapolation and meaningful differences hidden by averages. In qualitative work, examine the connection between the material, interpretation and claims; in bibliometric work, inspect database coverage and counting choices.

State which supplementary materials or resources were actually examined and any access limitations. Separate issues that threaten the central conclusion from improvements that would extend the study. Explain how each major concern affects interpretation and what proportionate clarification or evidence would resolve it.

Rights and contextual interpretation

Consider privacy, cultural authority, accessibility and the effects of classification on affected people. Respect legitimate restrictions and assess whether the proposed verification route is adequate. Reviewers should identify concerns for the editor without attempting to contact participants, obtain restricted records independently or impose public disclosure that conflicts with the research permissions.

What the review model means

The adopted model requires double-anonymous review and at least two independent external expert reports for scholarly articles. The handling editor assesses the evidence and makes the decision; reports are advice rather than votes.

Read the complete peer review policy